RSS/Atom feed Twitter
Site is read-only, email is disabled

Can't save bug?

This discussion is connected to the gimp-user-list.gnome.org mailing list which is provided by the GIMP developers and not related to gimpusers.com.

This is a read-only list on gimpusers.com so this discussion thread is read-only, too.

3 of 3 messages available
Toggle history

Please log in to manage your subscriptions.

Can't save bug? Ian H 04 Nov 00:53
  Can't save bug? Gary Aitken 05 Nov 16:17
  Can't save bug? gmatht 11 Feb 00:47
Ian H
2013-11-04 00:53:12 UTC (over 10 years ago)

Can't save bug?

I recently encountered a very frustrating situation and am wondering if it's a bug or "feature".

I was working on an image, it was quite big, 7000 px wide, 6000 tall but only 5 quite simple layers, the .xcf is 7.8MB.

All of a sudden after pasting from another .xcf file (which I had just 10+ times with no similar result) I moved the pasted part, the image was pretty much finished and I went up to click file>export and everything between "open recent" and "quit" in the file menu was grey. No chance to save or export and it appears half an hour of work lost. It was as if the file menu didn't think I had a file open, but if I scrolled accross to the filters menu for example, they were available for selection which they are not when you have no image open. I could edit the image and change layer visibilities and do what I wanted to the image - except save it. I had flash backs to darker days of shareware version of lesser softer titles on proprietary systems. In a moment of frustration I hit the little "x" to resign for the night and it warned me to save before closing.. I hit save as the only option was to overwrite a file I didn;t really want to overwrite but I did and then wrote this.

Any ideas? It's 2.8.6 running on an up to date ubuntu 13.10 on a high end PC.

Ian

Gary Aitken
2013-11-05 16:17:27 UTC (over 10 years ago)

Can't save bug?

On 11/03/13 17:53, Ian H wrote:

I recently encountered a very frustrating situation and am wondering if it's a bug or "feature".

I was working on an image, it was quite big, 7000 px wide, 6000 tall but only 5 quite simple layers, the .xcf is 7.8MB.

All of a sudden after pasting from another .xcf file (which I had just 10+ times with no similar result) I moved the pasted part, the image was pretty much finished and I went up to click file>export and everything between "open recent" and "quit" in the file menu was grey. No chance to save or export and it appears half an hour of work lost. It was as if the file menu didn't think I had a file open, but if I scrolled accross to the filters menu for example, they were available for selection which they are not when you have no image open. I could edit the image and change layer visibilities and do what I wanted to the image - except save it. I had flash backs to darker days of shareware version of lesser softer titles on proprietary systems. In a moment of frustration I hit the little "x" to resign for the night and it warned me to save before closing.. I hit save as the only option was to overwrite a file I didn;t really want to overwrite but I did and then wrote this.

Any ideas? It's 2.8.6 running on an up to date ubuntu 13.10 on a high end PC.

To at least save the work and preserve the original, rename the original .xcf file outside of gimp, then do the save before quitting.

I am running 2.8.6 on fbsd and have never seen this. I have images a lot larger than that (41,000 x 3,000 px) and have had no problem other than running out of temp file space. In that case, the gimp warned me and I reconfigured; so I don't think it is related to the image size.

Were there any error messages in the console display?

I don't know under what circumstances the items under the file menu are greyed out other than no image; even if the image is read-only they are still active, so it's a total mystery to me. It does sound like it somehow got its head wedged thinking no file was open.

I presume you can't reproduce the problem?

Gary

2014-02-11 00:47:21 UTC (about 10 years ago)
postings
1

Can't save bug?

All of a sudden after pasting from another .xcf file (which I had just 10+ times with no similar result) I moved the pasted part, the image was pretty much finished and I went up to click file>export and everything between "open recent" and "quit" in the file menu was grey. No chance to save or export and it appears half an hour of work lost.

Are you using Ubuntu Unity? If so this sounds a lot like a known bug: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/unity-gtk-module/+bug/1263205

Try using something other than Unity (e.g. KDE, LXDE) or run sudo apt-get remove indicator-appmenu to disable this "feature".